Results at a Glance
+68%
Combined Lead Volume
More leads across both dealership locations
-32%
Cost Per Lead
Lead volume up 68% combined across both stores
+44%
Appointment Rate
Marketing-sourced leads converting to showroom visits
+100%
Attribution Clarity
Both stores' campaign economics on one view
Background
David Blake manages two Ford dealerships in completely different markets: Lake Powell Ford in Page, AZ (a small tourist town near the Grand Canyon) and Alamo Ford in San Antonio, TX (a massive metro with intense competition). Each store has different inventory strategies, competitive dynamics, and customer demographics. Managing marketing across both was complex, and the previous approach treated them as one-size-fits-all.
The Challenge
Managing marketing across two distinct markets with different competition levels, customer demographics, and inventory strategies. Page, AZ is a small rural market where most of the search volume is local; San Antonio is a major metro where the group competes with dozens of Ford dealers. Budget allocation between the two stores had no unified view of what was working where.
What We Changed
Multi-Location SEO
Market-specific keyword strategies and local optimization for each dealership location: what works in rural Arizona is completely different from what wins in San Antonio. Each store got a custom SEO plan built for its specific competitive landscape
Unified PPC Strategy
Coordinated Google Ads and Facebook campaigns with location-specific budgets and targeting, but managed from a single dashboard so David can see both stores' performance side-by-side and shift budget where it's working best
Attribution Tracking
Single reporting dashboard showing performance across both locations with clear attribution. David knows exactly which campaigns at which store are driving appointments and sold units. No more guessing where to allocate budget
Website Management
Centralized content strategy with location-specific pages and inventory integration. Each store's website speaks to its local market while maintaining brand consistency across the group
Before & After
The Impact
Both dealerships saw substantial improvements in lead quality and volume. Lead volume grew 68% combined across the two stores and cost per lead fell 32% over the 18-month window, as budget moved from the campaigns and locations with the highest cost per lead to the ones producing appointments. Appointment rate grew 44%. The single-dashboard view is what makes the shift possible: both stores' campaign economics sit next to each other, so a budget move is a visible decision rather than a guess. The numbers in this study are the marketing-side metrics from the ad platforms and GA4; units sold per store are tracked in the DMS and are not included.
The Bottom Line
Two stores in very different markets, one dashboard, and budget that moves to where cost per lead is lowest: combined lead volume +68% and cost per lead -32% over 18 months. These are lead and cost metrics - sold units per store are a separate DMS number, not part of this study.
“Across the 18-month window, combined lead volume grew 68% and cost per lead fell 32% across the two stores, with appointment rate up 44%. The budget moves that got us there are visible in the shared dashboard, store by store.”
Savvy Dealer
Two-Store 18-Month Performance Review
Lake Powell Ford & Alamo Ford
Key Takeaways
Multi-location groups need market-specific strategies: what works in rural AZ won't work in metro TX
Unified reporting across locations lets you shift budget to what's working in real time
Cost per lead dropped 32% by eliminating waste from one-size-fits-all targeting
Appointment rate improvements (+44%) matter more than raw lead volume: quality over quantity drives sold units
Services Used
Learn More About These Services
Want Similar Results for Your Dealership?
Get a free marketing audit to see how we can drive measurable improvements for your dealership.
More Case Studies
Bob Weaver Collision Center
Pottsville, PA
A collision center site rebuilt on its own domain: Google search impressions up 7.5x in four months, page one for near-me and insurer searches, and cost per click cut by two thirds on the same ad budget.
Madisonville Ford
Madisonville, TX
New site live in late April. By August, organic search was the store's number one traffic source, ahead of paid search, with model pages ranking inside 90 days.
Thayer Auto Group
Bowling Green, OH
Six franchises, one hand-built paid Google playbook: paid sessions across the group 2.1x in 60 days at 65% to 96% engagement, and the gains held through summer.